After shuddering at the thought of Rod Stewart covering "Fooled Around And Fell In Love" - which I promptly, in all my infinite wisdom declared "The worst song ever recorded with the word 'love' in the title"* - we decided to make our own lists of both the worst and best songs with "Love" in the title. As we started down that path we discovered that there were, much to our collective consternation, a number of songs which hung out in a fourth dimension of sorts - songs which could be considered in both categories simultaneously - sort of "quantum love songs" if you will. And so we added a third category (well some of us did, anyway).
Since there are thousands and thousands of songs fitting in one (or more - see above) of these categories, we welcome you to submit your own picks in the comments...
*Later I determined that this was, in fact only the fourth worst song with the word 'love' in the title - clearly I was being a bit rash and unfair...
Steve "Pull Your Love" Wilmart:
Top 5 -Best-
5. Love Cry - Albert Ayler
4. Love & Happiness - Al Green
3. Love For Sale - Abbey Lincoln (several good ones to choose from)
2. I Believe (When I Fall In Love It Will Be Forever) - Stevie Wonder
1. A Love Supreme - John Coltrane
Top 5 -Worst-
5. Love Will Keep Us Together - Captain & Tennille
4. Fooled Around And Fell In Love - Elvin Bishop
3. Love Grows (Where My Rosemary Goes) - Edison Lighthouse
2. Don't Pull Your Love - Hamilton, Joe Frank & Reynolds
1. Muskrat Love - Captain & Tennille
Top -Could go either way-
5. Love Stinks - J. Geils Band
4. True Love - Tiny Tim
3. Radar Love - Golden Earring
2. Love Machine - The Miracles
1. Love Rollercoaster - Ohio Players
0. Lick My Love Pump - Spinal Tap
-1. Love/Hate - Betty Blowtorch
Michael "Faded Love" Townsend:
BEST:
Soldier of Love - Arthur Alexander
Love Like This - Faith Evans
Lagan Love - Irish trad.
Love In Outer Space - Sun Ra
Faded Love - Bob Wills
WORST:
To Sir With Love - Lulu
I Just Called To Say I Love You - Stevie Wonder
Tell Laura I Love Her - Ray Peterson
Why Do Fools Fall In Love - Frankie Lymon
Love Me Tender - Elvis Presley
GUILTIEST PLEASURES:
Somebody To Love - Jefferson Airplane
Look Of Love - Burt Bacharach
Addicted To Love - Robert Palmer
Everybody Loves Somebody - Dean Martin
Tom "Love In My Tummy" RuttenbeckAGIN’
1 - Let’s weep along with Torn Between Two Lovers & I Honestly Love You,
2 - Anything rendered by Phil Collins, e.g., You Can't Hurry Love & A Groovy Kind Of Love.
3 - A Paul McCartney medley: My Love, Silly Love Songs & Beware My Love. (Any more?)
4 - The Partridge Family’s I Think I Love You.
5 - And everybody knows that Yummy Yummy Yummy ain't the whole title.
5a - ARS’s “spooky” Imaginary Lover can’t beat (!) Richard Thompson’s Read About Love.
FER
1 - Have You Every Loved A Woman - Eric Clapton
2 - I Do It For Your Love - Paul Simon
3 – I Love’s You, Porgy - Fitzgerald/Simone/Davis, etc.
4 - Love Struck Baby - Stevie Ray Vaughan
5 - Zepplin’s Whole Lotta Love (come on, it moved you)
5a - Robert Palmer’s Addicted To Love has that momentary clash of scimitars
Corey "Medical Love" Edwards:
bad
Creatures of Love - Talking Heads
Get Down, Make Love - Queen
Looking For Love - The Cars
City Of Love - Yes
Love Me Do - Beatles
good
True Love - Fred Frith
Impossible Love - Daniel Johnston
She's In Love - Brenda Kahn
Love You - Syd Barrett
Medical Love Song - Monty Python
both
I Hope That I Don't Fall In Love With You - Tom Waits
I Love You, You Big Dummy - Captain Beefheart
Satellite of Love - Lou Reed
Chris "I Need Love" Gunn:
top 5 best. . .
1. "All You Need Is Love" Beatles
2. "One Love" Bob Marley
3. "Love & Happiness" Al Green
4. "Make You Feel My Love" Bob Dylan
5. "Love Supreme" John Coltrane
and 5 worst. . .
1. "Can't Buy Me Love" Beatles
2. "Love Me Two Times" Doors
3. "Greatest Love Of All" Whitney Houston
4. "Love Is A Rose" Linda Ronstadt
5. "I Need Love" LL Cool J
Let your comments - like your love - flow...